Wednesday, February 27, 2008

RIP

His name was Matthew Manger-Lynch.

Not nearly as tragic, but sad none the less, to see that the Chicago Tribune editors cannot resist the urge to inject a soft undercurrent of anti-bike vitriol into even the most somber of cases.

4 comments:

jmgorman said...

With the tragedy so fresh, the editor's comments are uncomfortable, but are they vitriolic?

Though I didn't know Matt at all, his death has left me shaken. As a cyclist who often takes part in and organises alleycats I find myself asking a lot of the questions the editors are addressing. From a decidedly different perspective, I'm coming to some of the same conclusions. I'll not participate in any further alleycats as a racer or (certainly not!) as an organiser. While I do not hold the organisers of the TdC accountable, I could not bear, in the event of such a tragedy, the strain they are currently experiencing.

I think the editors are right to examine alleycats in the larger context of bicycle advocacy and transportation safety. Calling attention to the apparent hypocrisy of persistently-complaining cyclists when some of their number intentionally endanger themselves is short-sighted, but not vitriolic. I know that I have personally done damage to my local cycling community because of my conduct in alleycats - to pretend otherwise is not helpful to myself or that community. I do not, as the editors seem to, believe that alleycats and underground racing are necessarily harmful, but I can see their potential for harm both to the racers and those with whom, like the driver of the SUV that collided with Matt, we must share the road.

strangelife said...

jmgorman- After a second and third read of the Tribune's story, perhaps "vitriol" wasn't the best word choice. Regardless, the article strikes a consistently negative tone toward cyclists. Though my reflexive bias may be reading between the lines looking for scapegoats other than the culture I choose to stand with, I believe "vitriol", while perhaps too strong a word, represents the way I interpret it.

Thanks for your well reasoned input.

s.

Jason said...

Hey Strangelife,

I am just delving into your blog having been pointed over from Le Grimpeur. I'm a Chicago bike rider too. I have read many stories about bike issues that I have decried, but I didn't really find anything objectionable in that piece. I myself have been known to break some laws, etc. riding around, but I really can't get any wind in my sails about defending myself doing this.

As tragic as this death is, it's really hard to find a balanced point of view on dudes screaming through red lights in traffic. It's a pretty cut and dry thing to me. I go through red lights, but I certainly don't expect any cars to stop or in any way, make exception for my unlawful actions.

I commend you for your ability to think through your original post, but I have to sit with the Tribune (blech) on this particular piece.

In other news, I hope to run into you sometime, great blog! I am more of a born again biker than a longtime road rider, but I think that aside, I am finding all your cultural references sounding like we grew up together!

best,
Jason Ward
jason@jasonward.org

Jason said...

Hey Strangelife,

I am just delving into your blog having been pointed over from Le Grimpeur. I'm a Chicago bike rider too. I have read many stories about bike issues that I have decried, but I didn't really find anything objectionable in that piece. I myself have been known to break some laws, etc. riding around, but I really can't get any wind in my sails about defending myself doing this.

As tragic as this death is, it's really hard to find a balanced point of view on dudes screaming through red lights in traffic. It's a pretty cut and dry thing to me. I go through red lights, but I certainly don't expect any cars to stop or in any way, make exception for my unlawful actions.

I commend you for your ability to think through your original post, but I have to sit with the Tribune (blech) on this particular piece.

In other news, I hope to run into you sometime, great blog! I am more of a born again biker than a longtime road rider, but I think that aside, I am finding all your cultural references sounding like we grew up together!

best,
Jason Ward
jason@jasonward.org